Step 1

Mix the breadcrumbs (panko) and Old Bay Seasoning in a small bowl. In another bowl mix beat the egg with a fork.

Step 2

Take your fish, dip it into the egg on both sides, and then dip it into the bread crumb mixture. Repeat with the remaining fish.

Step 3

Spray your basket with cooking spray. As you bread your fish, place them into the greased basket. Spray the breaded fish with cooking spray, which will help it crisp up.

Step 4

Set the temperature to 350 degrees F, air fryer setting, set the time for 10-12 minutes, flip the fish halfway, and then respond to the fish with cooking spray.

Step 5

Check the internal temperature before removing the fish, which should have a 145 degrees F reading. Remove the fish when it’s fully cooked. (The exact time is going to depend on what air fryer you own and how thick your fish is))

Step 6

Add your hamburger rolls to the air fryer basket, and air fry 2-3 minutes at 320 degrees F, remove once toasted.

Step 7

To Assemble the sandwich, place the tartar sauce on the bottom of the bottom bun, and then place the Crispy Fish Fillet on top, add a piece of American Cheese and cover with the top bun.

Step 8

Plate, serve, and enjoy!