Step 1

Wisk yogurt and milk together in the Instant Pot liner.

Step 2

Add sweetened condensed milk if choosing to sweeten. 1/2 can will just barely sweetened while still being plenty tangy. Choose as much or as little as you like.

Step 3

Close Instant Pot lid (no need to seal because it will not be coming to pressure. Choose YOGURT setting and make sure it is on NORMAL.

Step 4

Set time between 8-9 hours. 8 for less tangy, 9 for lots of tang. I choose 8.5 for balance.

Step 5

Go to bed, and wake up with yogurt ready to chill!

Step 6

When the timer goes off, you can either transfer the Instant Pot liner directly to the fridge for regular creamy yogurt and let chill for 8 hours OR

Step 7

Transfer the yogurt into your straining device of choice and chill in the fridge while straining.