Salt potatoes are a regional specialty of Syracuse, New York, a.k.a. The Salt City. Salt potatoes date to the 1800s, invented by local salt mine workers who created a simple and inexpensive lunch by boiling small potatoes in brine. The potatoes are still very popular today with the Central New York crowd, making an incredibly easy and delicious side dish.

Syracuse Salt Potatoes

potatoes

salt

butter, melted

Wash the potatoes and set aside. Fill a large pot with water; stir in salt until it no longer dissolves and settles on the bottom. Place potatoes in the pot and bring to a boil; reduce heat and simmer until potatoes are tender but firm, about 15 minutes. Drain; cover to keep hot.


While the potatoes are cooking, melt the butter in a small pan over medium high heat, or in microwave. Serve immediately poured over potatoes.


I have made these potatoes several times now, using baby reds... and they are WONDERFUL!  I think it should be noted for people (such as Aspiring Chef Rita) that the recipe calls for WHOLE potatoes, washed only... do not cut the potatoes up and do not peel them otherwise they will absorb the salt and become too salty.  When they are fork tender (about 15 minutes for me) drain them and let them sit to form the thin salt crust.  I sometimes add chives to my melted butter, just for some color and added flavor even though I know it is not traditional.  I have also boiled reds side by side, one pot with amount of salt this recipe calls for and one pot with just a little salt...and it's amazing how the salty brine makes the salt potatoes so creamy inside!  Made correctly, they are NOT salty... just creamy and delicious!  I served them alongside slow-roasted BBQ baby back pork ribs... mmmmmmmm... wonderful!

I was introduced to these salt potatoes a couple of years ago while visiting friends in upstate New York. I learned they were a big deal to people there, and I was eager to try the bag/kit of salt potatoes she picked up. The concept, she explained, was that the potatoes were boiled in copious amounts of salt that somehow made them flavorful and special. They were good, I thought, but tasted just like regular ol' boiled potatoes to me. In fact, they needed...salt! When I came across this recipe, I just had to try them again myself at home.  And once again I found them good, but tasting no different than regular ol' boiled potatoes - that needed...salt! 

DO NOT cut the potatoes prior to cooking! 
If only you could taste these with the Cornell barbecue chicken that one can find about any weekend of the summer around here(Ithaca, NY/Cornell area)you'd know what it's all about!!  You want them nice and tender, with plenty of butter, but not falling apart.  Also, make sure you are using small, young potatoes- not too big.

first, i want to say thank you for the recipe. I've never measured in terms of cups, it's always been a quarter pound of salt to every pound of potatoes. For all the people saying that these are regular boiled potatoes, they are too salty, not salty enough, etc.. the purpose of the salt is not so much to make the potatoes salty as it is to lower the boiling point of the water. With the different boiling point, it makes the flesh of the potato creamier than normal boiling and less starchy. As for the saltiness/needs salt problem, you may need to adjust the amount of water that you use. It doesn't specify in the recipe, but for this amount of salt and potatoes, you need 3 quarts of water. If you aren't using enough, you might as well eat the salt shaker and skip the potatoes

Okay, with 113 reviews on this recipe, I seriously doubt that MY review will ever be read but I'm posting it anyway. :D I love reading stories about architypal food that our ancestors ate. I stumbled upon an article on wikipedia about Syracuse Salt Potatoes and was absolutely enthralled with the story of Irish Salt Miners from the turn of the century. On Wikipedia, they had two recipe links. I followed THERE recipes and my family and I enjoyed a treat STRAIGHT FROM HEAVEN!!!! This is what I learned: 1) Use ONLY "NEW yellow or white potatoes!!!" Never-ever use red skin potatoes!!! 2) The ratio of salt to water is 1 cup of KOSHER SALT (never table salt) to 6 cups of water. 3) The salt must be completely dissolved IN the water before you put in the potatoes. 4) Boil them until tender, drain but DO NOT RINSE. Allow to cool until you can eat them and use melted butter to dip them into. I'm telling you, Syracuse Salt Potatoes will be served in our home from now on! :D

I've lived in the Syracuse area all my life...they are Always a summertime staple, the Best one's are the Hinderwadle's, some stores carry their "own" brand, but the Hinderwadle's are the "traditional" Salt Potato..for those who aren't too big on using the whole bag of salt when cooking the potatoes, try using a little more than half the bag. I always let the potatoes sit covered after draining for a bit before serving.

I love salt potatoes.  I used to live in Binghamton and would always get them at a local spiedie restaurant.  I am not really a potato lover but made like this, they are so yummy.  Make sure the potatoes are nice and small - so you can just pop them in your mouth in one bite!

I hate to spoil the 5 star rating but I have to.  Straight away you know that the amount of salt and butter used in this recipe is not good for you but since I love potatoes I decided to go for it.  No one ate more than a few bites!!!  The salt was a killer.  One person said that this was suicide on a plate.  In any event - for all those salt lovers - go for it!!!

The author forgot to add that salt potatoes are a summer cookout dish!  In fact they are a staple at any clam bake, BBQ or cookout in CNY.  I don't think I could eat them in the middle of winter.  But they go great with hotdogs on the grill and some corn on the cob, or even with some steamed clams.  I am a CNY native and always had salt potatoes growning up, I never knew they were regional until recently.

I'm from the midwest and had never heard of these.  I thought I would give them a try (just because I'm like that!) and was actually quite impressed with the change in the potatoes.  One would think that it really wouldn't be more than a salty potato...however, it's not salty.  They are creamy and wonderful.  I would offer one word of caution.  I made the mistake of making them alongside a rather mundane pot roast that I expected to be more flavorful than it was.  I would definitely recommend serving them with something with a much bolder flavor.  I saw someone said something about them being served with BBQ chicken and I could definitely see that.  I would just go with a bolder meat than pot roast with these...they deserve it!

Excellent. Do not peel the potatoes. The salt water adds a different flavor to the potatoes and they have a smoother consistency. When they come out of the water, they form a salt crust on the skins that is full of flavor.

These are a classic!!  There's no way they'll be too salty if you do it right.  The salt goes in the water, and most of it is poured off when the potatoes are drained.  DO NOT add the salt directly to the potatoes, it goes in the cooking water.  They're not going to be anything fancy, so adjust your expectations there.  They're potatoes cooked in salt water, it's not going to be a gourmet dish.  Just good, simple food that's immensely popular in this area!

Had this for the first time last week at my boyfriends brothers house upstate. Didn't think I was going to be impressed but I was. Added some fresh chives, yummy!

I grew up in central ny and have had this often. They are definitely different from regular boiled potatoes. Regular boiled potatoes get soggy and bland inside and mushy. Salt potatoes get a crispy skin and creamy inside. Let them sit after draining until they dry and get that thin salt film over the tops. The size should be small enough to eat the whole potato in one big full bite, and all around the same size. Don't bother with the recipe if they are medium sized because the point of salt potatoes is lost when you cut them to eat it. The way to enjoy them is to dip them in a little butter and eat the whole thing right off the fork. No cutting or mashing.

These were DA BOMB!!  Super creamy and perfectly seasoned and great with a sprinkling of green onions. Just made some simple sauced pork chops and hubby ate the Whole thing!  Yiippee:):) Thanks so much Kaspmary!! These are a keeper.

Grew up in Syracuse and these potatoes made many clambakes better!  Moved away and finally went back this year after 15+ years...the potatoes are still the same and this recipe is as close to the real thing as you can get.  I'll be introducing my friends in Eastern NC during the next Pirate tailgate!

This recipe does not state the amount of water needed which is 2 quarts for this much salt. Less water and the salt concentration is higher, more water lower. This 1.5 cups salt to 32 oz water works out perfect. I found small Green Giant red potatoes at Walmart of all places in a small mesh back for under $3, a little pricey but the result was great!

Very good! I have never made these before, but being raised by parents from Upstate NY, I've eaten them many times. I thought the ratio of salt and butter was perfect. Some reviews mentioned it being too salty, but the salt is boiled in the water, not placed directly on the cooked potatoes. Overall good flavor and I'll definitely make them again!

These are the best salt potatoes EVER!  I absolutely love the recipe and will make it again for sure.  To me, salt potatoes are potatoes done right.  I stuck to the recipe almost to the letter, but used 4 servings instead.  I had to guess a little with the salt and potatoes, but other than that I really didn't change the recipe.  I added in herbs from my garden that I had dried in my dehydrator while boiling.  I also lightly put in some Table Blend Style Mrs. Dash, my favorite  seasoning mix.  The result was wonderful!  Not only did I have fun making it, the dish was delicious!  I could not put it down!  If you are anyone who likes potatoes, give this recipe a try!

I'm a native of Syracuse and these are more than just a simple potato dish.  They are part of our lives and bring with them all the memories of family, friends and good times in the summer.  That's why we give the 5 stars.  In CNY we know reds from whites from yellows, etc. and we know what a raw potato tastes like from an early age. We like the flavors of potatoes without ketchup or mayo or sour cream or whatever else people use to mask the potato flavor. This recipe accentuates pure potato flavor.

Excellent and quick recipe. I added some bacon to it, and it was yummy!

I was so hopeful.....but disappointed! Don't understand what everyone is raving about.

I'm so glad to see that somebody out there has a recipe for this! I grew up near Syracuse and have been missing these!

Love this method! Just like little mashed potatoes packaged in a potato skin! Add a little chives, scallions, garlic, tarragon. Or just butter. Pure, simple decadence!

Very good potatoes.   I had never heard of them, so tried them.  Wonderful creamy texture and a light salt flavor.  Definately let them dry so you get the light salt coating on the skin.  A nice simple potatoe dish.   I followed the recipe, used baby reds.  Only addition was some fresh chives added to the butter.  Yum!

After reading the history behind these little potatoes, I just had to try.  It's really neat how the salt forms a thin crust around the potato.  Even though you think the salt would be overpowering, I found it no different than if I salted my french fries.  It's always fun to experience food from other parts of the region.  Thanks so much for sharing this recipe.

I am loving these potatoes! I used the larger red potatoes and cut them into 8ths before boiling. It cooked them a bit quicker. Wonderful quick potato dinner! Thanks so much! We will be eating these a lot.

Salt potatoes are just delicious!!  I am always disappointed I can't find the bag/kit outside of Upstate NY.  This recipe does a fine job, although I usually use Kosher/course salt.

I was impressed that such a simple recipe could be so tasty!  I've never been a fan of the texture of boiled potatoes, but these are completely different.  They are super creamy inside without being mushy.  The salt crust on the outside gives the impression that they will be overly salty, but they weren't at all.  In fact, they were perfectly salted.  I thought I had made far too many for the number of people I was serving, but everyone kept going back for more.  I got rave reviews and requests to make them again from everyone.  We had them with steak, but I think they would be perfect with almost anything.

These are the best!  To get the full taste I had someone drive 700 miles from Syracuse to bring me salt potaotes from Wegmans!  

These were great! Yes, it is a lot of salt, but the result is a buttery, smooth potato with a crispy, salty skin. We didn't serve with butter. They are perfect in their own!

My husband made these twice thinking that we didn't do something right the first time. These were not bad but, they tasted like plain potatoes that needed salt. Nothing special. Will not be making these again.

These are really tasty! I only used 1/2 the butter, and just drizzled it over the top. 

Mmmmm.  Very, very good.  Mine took closer to 25-30 minutes to boil but they were on the larger side.  Perfect with BBQ smoked pork.  Mmmmm.

Wow! What an awesome dish! I made these for my girlfriend's birthday dinner tonight and we were both blown away by these little nuggets of goodness. I used Teeny Tiny Potatoes from Trader Joe's and followed the tip from another reviewer about the proportion of salt:water. Since I had a 1# bag of potatoes, I used 3/8 c. salt: 2 cups water. The salt crust formed just as described. Sooo delish and super easy. We will definitely make these again!

Perfect with or without the butter.  Husband likes his buttery, I like them plain, and the salty flavor is excellent every time.  Very simple to make.

This is a definite dish at any CNY summer gathering! It's important to use small whole potatoes, and let them sit after draining so the salt crust forms. My mom always mixed real butter and margarine to help cut the fat. Give them a chance ... you will understand why ALL of CNY'er's LOVE Salt Potatoes!  They are creamy and delicious ... the salt adds a bonus flavor that is not too overpowering.

Soo glad I found this recipe. We used to have these at clambakes every year growing up. I'm originally from WNY right on lake ontario. I moved out to the midwest and nobody here new what I was talking about. But this recipe is just what I remeber as a kid! Add a chopped parsely oy chives to the butter for a little extra kick! 

I love these potatoes, but according to the original recipe (and trial and error), using Non-Iodized salt tastes the best and using red potatoes only.  Also, add chopped green onions to the butter before melting.  Yummy!

My husband and father loved them. I followed the directions except (i know, i know) I let each individual add butter to theirs if they wanted it. I did like the salt crust and the insides of the potatoes were not salty at all. Really good.

Yum - and really not salty at all.  I didn't get as much of a salt crust as other people said (maybe too much water?), but  they were good anyway.  My 15 year old (who doesn't like potatoes at all)  really liked these.  Used up all the salt in the house, though!

A blast from the past. Such a delicious and simple side dish. You can throw in some fresh dill or parsley etc for looks, but these are so tasty they really don't need anything else. These are best served the same day...they lose some of their flavor as leftovers the next day.

Grew up in Western NY, but now live in Ottawa, Ontario and always had these potatoes at the fairs.  What a nice reminder of home.  Made a 1/2 batch and they were perfect! Thanks.

A sure sign of summer or a NYer's wishful longing: Salt potatoes and grilled Italian marinated chicken! I bought some prewashed baby potatoes earlier today and plan to use them for this tonight- Got the winter blues.

I make these every summer for my husband with Cornell Chicken. Growing up in the Finger Lake Region, he misses summer bbq's badly.

Absolutely perfect.  I grew up near Binghamton, NY and this recipe is a dead ringer.  Totally reminds me of being a kid at the Irish festival at Grippen Park in Endicott. Thank you so much!

I live in Florida and made these for a dear friend orignally from New York... He LOVED THEM... he said it brought back fond memories~~~

I grew up in Upstate NY, and was shocked to find out that no one on the West Coast knew what Salt Potatoes were! My mom &amp; I used to always buy the bags of potatoes at the store that came with a packet of salt inside, so I used this recipe to get the salt measurement right. I usually get either baby gold potatoes or new red potatoes. As long as they as small, with thin skin, and never cut. My husband &amp; in-laws are now hooked. :)

Being an Upstate New York native I have made these for years and its important to make sure to use very small potatoes, no larger than 2 inches in diameter.  Also, only use a little more water than you need to cover the spuds. That way you won't dilute the yummy salty flavor, since that's what we're after here with this dish.

Simple and delish, thank you for posting.

I grew up just outside Binghamton New York and now live in Missouri.My parents always bring bags of this out when they come.This along with spiedie sauce.Make sure you use small potatoes.It was great to see so many people that knew what they were.

Up there with some of the best potatoes in the world. Really is there anything better then salty buttery potatoes. I think not. Not overly salty at all. It was almost like mashed potatoes inside. So creamy so yummy. I used purple potatoes and browned my butter a tad because I love the nuttiness of brown butter. So very good I know I will be making this dish often. Thank you!

Nice soft buttery potatoes. My son said, "Mom, why don't you make the potatoes like this all the time."

I love salt potatoes!!  I'm from Upstate NY and trappers is right about the Cornell bbq too!  (glad to say I have that recipe too as we live in another state now!)  We used to eat these potatoes at the carnivals.

I LOVE these potatoes!  They taste fantastic and my roommates loved them too.  Be careful to balance out your potato weight and the water/salt ratio, the first time I made this I incorrectly guestimated my potatos and it was almost too salty.  The second (and third and fourth and fifth!) times it was fantastic and my roommates beg me to make this all the time!

These were very tasty, took longer to cook than listed, but delicious.  It made too much for me, next time I will try cutting in half as I don't have a large family.

So completely and totally surprised by these. I've NEVER had potatoes this creamy!!! So glad I stumbled upon this recipe!

This was delicious and simple!  I put about 2lbs of small-medium red, purple and gold potatoes in a pot &amp; covered generously with water.  I added one cup of salt (my that's  a lot of salt when you have it all measured out) and allowed it to come to a boil.  Then, I simmered those potato butts for 20-25 minutes.

What came out was amazing!  Taken out with a slotted spoon and patiently waiting for them to dry, a soft salt crust developed around the skin making it look like my potatoes were precious jewels.

I devoured them immediately.  I loved how the outside skin was salty and chewy and the inside "meat" though slightly bland, was creamy and soft and paired well with the salty exterior.  Even my boyfriend (whom displayed no interest upon hearing how these were made) readily ate a few.

No need for butter.  These make for perfect snacks on the go!

I just moved out to Syracuse area, and had these at a fair. They were amazing so I searched and found this recipe!! I made them for my family and 2 dinner guests! They were a big hit and a new favorite in my house. I did add a little extra salt after pouring the butter over them.

The simplicity was appealing, and I followed the recipe precisely. What I found was an over salted, potato with an unpleasant texture and bite.

They are SOOOO good made just as written!

I am from upstate Ny and had no idea salt potatoes are a regional speciality. Thanks for the recipe. These are good for potlucks, clambakes, and cookouts.

As a Syracuse native I was excited to see this recipe on here. Now if I could just find those perfectly tiny potatoes grandma used to use....although baby reds do fine :)

These are a treat.  I used fingerling potatoes and kosher salt, but I made sure I had a nice salty brine.  My guests raved about how good they were.  The outside had a slight salty crust and the potatoes were silky and creamy.  Thanks kapsmary, this is a keeper!

I had Salt Potatoes 1 time and have not been able to forget the yummyness.  I finally found a recipe and made it right away.  The only thing I did differently because the potatoes used for this recipe are so expensive is make a fourth of the recipe posted here.  Also I added Garlic Salt.  Once I made the recipe and tasted it, it seemed quite bland.  Garlic Salt did the trick!!!!!!  YEAH!!!!!  The family loved it and it brought me back to Watertown, NY.

I am from Rochester/Buffalo Ny area, and no summer picnic, BBQ, or clam bake is complete without salt potatoes! I never put butter on top of them bc I prefer them plain with the salty crust. If you skip the butter then you can eat them cold for breakfast the next morning. Yum!

Good and different. This was the first time I ever tried these and it was really good from the same old potatoes.

Were ok, nothing special.  Might make again.

Very good....followed recipe as stated.  Potatoes did change in consistency and were very creamy and smooth.  Topped with  the melted butter with a little Thyme.....perfect pairing with baked chicken.  Will make again!

I have been eating these treats for about 40 years, and I have to agree with "Naples34102".  They can be bland.  And what I do to prevent this, is add the potatoes and the salt at the same time, while the water is at a full boil.  The rest of the recipe is the same.  Be sure to have plenty of melted butter on hand.  Those of you who live in upstate NY should relish this treat...you can't get in any where else, unles you do it yourself.  And there are no kits outside of that area.  I'm giving this recilpe 4 stars, only because I think adding the salt with the potatoes makes them salter, and more deserving of 5.  Oh, and I prefer sea salt, or kosher salt over the "fine" salt called for.  Just my preferance.

Wonderful.  They are like creamy mashed potatoes in bite size form.  Perfectly portable and super easy to make

I grew up eating these every summer at my grandparents house in Fulton, NY!  I am so happy to find this recipe!  Having them for dinner tonight!  I can remember my grandmother just throwing a big chunk of butter in the pan with the drained potatoes and we would always get yelled at for standing at the stove eating them right out of the pot!

We didn't love them.  They were fine potatoes but nothing special.

I recently moved to Syracuse and kept seeing the salt potato bags at the store...picked up bag, tried this recipe (and learned some history) and the whole family LOVES them.

Added fresh chives to the butter. Delicious.

These were very tasty. The salt was not overpowering at all as some reviewers had mentioned.

These are yummy, not too salty.  Much cheaper than buying the kit to make Salt Potatoes...they are just potatoes packed with a bag of salt!  I reheated mine in the Crock Pot...which I wouldn't recommend.  Great at a picnic.

I'd never heard of these until we moved to the PA/NY border almost 15 years ago.  However, they are a family favorite.  We get these at every local festival and make them for every backyard barbecue.  Make them exactly as described -- no need to dress them up.

I was introduced to these while working in NNY building Fort Drum.  They sold the packages of 4 lb potatoes and 1 lb salt so I tried it.  The first time I kept the potatoes at a rolling boil until done.  The next day I spent 30 minutes washing the salt residue off the stove. ;)  I like to lightly smash a potato and put just a tad bit of butter on.   These really do go great with BBQ and other bold flavored dishes.  I Love them.  Brings back fond memories of the great food and wonderful people of Upstate NY.  They also go well with the killer Buffalo Wings I bought in a small store in Pamelia.

My husband and I met in Syracuse - and he is from Potsdam (way upstate) - he is ALWAYS asking for salt potatoes as a side dish. This recipe gave me the ratios I needed to make him happy. Thanks :)

My husband is from upstate New York and introduced me to salt potatoes on one of our visits. I would only ever get them once a yr. when we traveled there. I would purchase several bags of salt potatoes to bring home, then I got smart and realized I could do them on my own with new potatoes and salt. I am in love with salt potatoes, and if done properly they are not extremely salty.

I grew up in Upstate NY and love my salt potatoes although I changed up how I made them over the years.  I actually boil my potatoes in butter (salted) instead of water.  I also add a little extra salt because I prefer my 'salt potatoes' to actually have a salty flavor.  After moving to VA I discovered that although there are no baby potatoes to be found on a regular basis I can use fingerling potatoes and they're just as delicious. I also like to sprinkle a little parsley in the butter more for looks than anything else.

I do not get the hupla over these potatoes.  Really, really no big deal.  I would not bother to make these again

Just excellent!  These are great with barbequed chicken.

I live downstate so I had not come across these before. OMG...the flavor is amazing. I did add some parsley flakes and Mrs. Dash garlic/herb seasoning and the leftovers were so good! Now I know why I was never a fan of potatoes before...lack of flavor. Thanks for the recipe :-)

delicious  the nutritional information is pretty funny though :D

WONDERFUL!!!! I am from Syracuse, New York and have been eating these since I was a young girl. These are FABULOUS!!!

Yum!  These were great!  As a midwestern gal I had never had anything like these but I was pleasantly surprised.  These worked great with the "B" Red Potatoes that are always on sale at our grocery store. The smaller the potatoes the better so you get the best texture.

This was such an easy - delicious recipe. I grew up in Syracuse and these were a summer staple. I wish I could've gotten them a little more salt-encrusted though. Wonder if there are any tips out there for that?  I simmered the butter on the stove and made it nice and brown so it was a little caramelized- delish!

These are great!  When made properly, they are amazingly creamy on the inside and very lightly crusted with salt on the outside.

This is how it's done!  These potatoes are SUPPOSED to be salty and buttery! No one ever said "health food". We said SALT POTATOES!  Delicious!

I just used baby red fingerling potatoes for this.  They are suprisingly decent--not sure I'm sold on pouring that much salt into water then dumping it out, but for a simple dish, not bad.  I did as one reviewer suggested and let them sit--they really do form an outer salty crust, so you don't really need any salt or butter to add to them.  Definitely, though, these aren't something you want to use big potatoes for!  I'm not even sure I'm going to look at the sodium content for these and am glad I don't need to watch my sodium.  Not bad for a quick side dish.  Thanks for the recipe!

I was expecting more. The potatoes were creamy but nothing special, flavor wise.

My daughter and I loved these, although the other four family members seemed pretty indifferent. I will be adding this to my regular potato "rotation." Thanks for a fun new recipe.

syracuse salt potatoes

Prep Time: 10 minutes

Cook Time: 20 minutes

Total: 30 minutes

Servings: 8

Cost: $1.66 /serving

Author : kaspmary

Ingredients

Instructions

Top Similar Recipes from Across the Web

Syracuse Salt Potatoes

Syracuse Salt Potatoes

Syracuse Salt Potatoes Recipe

Syracuse Salt Potatoes Recipe (+ Th...

Salt Potatoes

Salt-Roasted Potatoes

Salt & Vinegar Crispy Potatoes

Salt & Vinegar Melting Potatoes

Instant Pot Salt Potatoes

Modern Grilled Salt Potatoes Recipe...

Salt and Vinegar Roasted Potatoes

Portuguese Salt Crusted Baked Potat...

Crispy Salt & Vinegar Fingerling Po...

Salt Potatoes New York Style

Crispy Salt and Vinegar Smashed Pot...

Sauté potatoes with sea salt & rose...

Red Lobster Salt Crusted Baked Pota...

Roasted Garlic and Rosemary Salt Po...

Crispy salt and pepper smashed pota...