Try my new budgeting app Cheddar 🧀
Better than YNAB, Mint (RIP), or EveryDollar.
5.0
(5)
Export 16 ingredients for grocery delivery
Step 1
Bring beef to room temperature: Remove the beef from the refrigerator at least 1 ½ and up to 2 hours before cooking to bring to room temperature. (Don’t skip this step – it’s the key to tender, evenly cooked beef). IMMEDIATELY go to step 2 and SALT BEEF according to the instructions below.)
Step 2
Salt beef: Sprinkle ¾ teaspoon kosher salt all over the top of the beef and use your hands to rub the salt into the beef. Flip the beef over and repeat the process of sprinkling with ¾ teaspoon of salt and massaging salt into beef. Set beef aside and let come to room temperature as indicated above.
Step 3
Make compound butter: In a medium mixing bowl, combine the butter, minced garlic, chopped rosemary, chopped thyme, 1 teaspoon of kosher salt and 1 teaspoon of cracked black pepper. Use a fork and mix until fully combined. Set aside.
Step 4
Preheat oven: Adjust oven rack to the bottom third position. Preheat oven to 500 degrees F (standard) or 475 degrees F (convection).
Step 5
Dry beef & smear with butter: Once beef is at room temperature, gently pat the beef dry with paper towels. Spread 2 tablespoons of the compound butter evenly over one side of the beef. (Tip: If you have a fat cap on your beef, you want to butter the bottom side. You will flip the beef over so it’s roasting with the fat cap facing UP in step 7.)
Step 6
Prepare roasting pan: Add the onions, carrots and garlic halves to the bottom of a roasting pan to create a bed.
Step 7
Add beef: Place the beef, butter side DOWN on top of the vegetables. Spread 4 tablespoons of the compound butter evenly on top of the beef.
Step 8
Brown: Transfer the roasting pan to the oven and roast for 10 minutes. Remove from oven. REDUCE OVEN TEMPERATURE TO 225 degrees F (standard).
Step 9
Add herbs and remaining butter: Add the sprigs of rosemary and thyme along with the bay leaves to the roasting pan. Carefully spread or dollop the remaining 2 tablespoons of butter evenly on top of the beef. Insert a meat thermometer into the center of the beef.
Step 10
Slow Roast: Transfer the roasting pan to the oven. Slow roast the beef for 30 minutes.
Step 11
Season mushrooms: Place the mushrooms in a bowl. Drizzle with 1 tablespoon of olive oil and season with salt and pepper. Toss to coat. Set aside.
Step 12
Add mushrooms and continue to roast: Remove the roasting pan from the oven and add the mushrooms to the pan, arranging them on the sides of the beef. Return pan to oven and continue to roast for an additional 40 to 60 minutes, or until the internal temperature is 115-118 degrees for medium-rare. (SEE NOTES)
Step 13
Rest: Remove the beef from the roasting pan and transfer to a serving plate or cutting board. Use a slotted spoon remove the mushrooms to a serving bowl. Cover the beef and mushrooms loosely with aluminum foil. Rest for 20+ minutes (the internal temperature of the beef will continue to rise 8-10 minutes during resting).
Step 14
Make the gravy: (You should have about 2 tablespoons of fat in the pan. If you don’t have a lot of fat, add butter to make up for the lack of drippings.) Remove and discard the onion, garlic and carrots. Place the pan over medium-high heat and add the wine to deglaze, scraping up any brown bits from the bottom of the pan. Bring to a rapid simmer and cook until the wine is reduced by half, about 5 minutes. Add the stock, Worcestershire and season to taste with salt and pepper. Stir to combine and bring the sauce back to a rapid simmer. Simmer for 10 minutes, or until the liquid is reduced by half again. Mix the cornstarch with the water. Slowly drizzle the mixture into the pan while whisking constantly to avoid lumping. Simmer until the sauce is thickened, about 2 minutes. OPTIONAL: Turn the heat to low and stir in heavy cream to taste. Remove from heat and adjust for seasoning with salt and pepper. Transfer the sauce to a gravy boat.
Step 15
Serve: Thinly slice the beef against the grain. Serve with mushrooms and drizzle with gravy. Enjoy!