How To Make In a tin, add Sailor Jerry spiced rum, lemon cordial and lemon juice with ice. Shake and strain into a Collins glass filled with fresh ice. Top with club soda. Garnish with a skewered lemon wheel and maraschino cherry. To make lemon cordial: Add 1 quart lemon juice + 1 quart of white granulated sugar and 5 lemon peels in a container and let sit overnight. Remove peels and stir mixture and bottle. Adding an ounce of Sailor Jerry spiced rum to the cordial will help it keep for several weeks.