Step 1

Spread butter on one side of each bread slice. Flip slices over and spread with peanut butter. Spread preserves onto one slice and top with remaining bread slice, buttered-side-up.

Step 2

Adjust the cooking rack to the center position if possible, otherwise use the bottom position.

Step 3

Place sandwich directly in the center of the toaster oven cooking rack.

Step 4

Set toaster oven to TOAST on MEDIUM and cook until bread is toasted about 2½ to 3 minutes, adding more time as needed.

Step 5

Use tongs or a spatula to carefully remove the sandwich. Cool slightly, then slice in half and dig in!