You'll need just five ingredients to feed a crowd these tender and tangy Italian beef sandwiches. On weekends, I start the roast the night before, so I can shred it in the morning. &mdash;Lori Piatt, Danville, Illinois

Italian Beef Hoagies

beef sirloin tip roast (4 pounds), halved

Italian salad dressing mix

water

(16 ounces) mild pickled pepper rings, undrained

hoagie buns, split

So unbelievably tasty! This was my first time ever using a crockpot and the meat came out tender and I could shred it after 8 1/2 hours on low. I followed the recipe exactly but  only used half the jar of mild banana peppers (with the liquid). I think the whole jar might have detracted from the delicious taste of the meat. I will make this many times in the future! We loved it.

Dissapointed, nothing like the Italian beef that my born and raised in Chicago family loves. I know it’s not the thin sliced gaucho beef, but we at least thought the gravy would be close. This was a huge fail for us.

My husband was not looking forward to another crock pot failure...boy was he surprised! This is now his 'go-to' beef dish.  I ended up leaving it in the slow cooker for almost 12 hours, so it was very tender and the pickled peppers were the perfect topper.  Thanks Taste of Home for a great recipe!

I've made this repeatedly and it is fantastic! The meat is so tender and flavorful and the recipe couldn't be easier.  I do not alter the ingredients, but I do reserve some of the liquid left in the slow cooker to mix with the meat and peppers.

Just made these for a family gathering. My sister in law asked for the recipe in her Christmas stocking!I took the roast out, cooled and strained the the liquid. It was too greasy the first time I made it, but after getting the excess fat out of the broth, it was excellent.

One of my most favorite recipes from Taste of Home!  Everyone in my family loves it and leftovers taste great! I highly recommend this recipe! Great for game days too!

I have made these several times now for potlucks at our church and it always goes over well.  Could not find a sirloin tip roast the last time I made it, but the butcher said a tri-tip roast would be a good substitute...it worked fine.

Good flavor & was easy to make. I was disappointed that the meat didn't shred for me, but was okay sliced. I was trying not to overcook it & make it dry, so maybe that's where I went wrong. I stopped at 8 hours in the crock pot on low.

very easy and delicious.Made it to bring to work and everyone loved it!

Wow!  These sandwiches were super yummy!  The perfect game day meal.  I will for sure make these again.

not impressed, beef did not get as tender as i hoped, a little dry peppery flavor overpowered the flavor of the meat

I have made this two times, and it just isn't that great. Seems like it is missing something, but I don't know what.

I put the roast in frozen!  No water needed, added minced garlic and used the HOT pepper rings.. YUMMY.  Going on 7 years with this recipe. FANTASTIC!!

My husband was not looking forward to another crock pot failure...boy was he surprised! After making this twice, this is now his 'go-to' beef dish.  I ended up leaving it in the slow cooker for almost 12 hours, so it was very tender and the pickled peppers were the perfect topper.  Thanks Taste of Home for a great recipe!

It was a big hit.  The flavor was delicious.  I couldn't find the meat it called for, so I used beef brisket. It still tasted great.  My mom likes hers with horseradish mayo. Yummm!

I have been making this for years!  My family loves it.  It always comes out very tender and flavorful!

italian beef hoagies

Prep Time: 25 minutes

Cook Time: 8 hours

Total: 8 hours, 25 minutes

Servings: 18

Author : Taste of Home

Ingredients

Instructions

Top Similar Recipes from Across the Web

Italian Beef Hoagies

Slow Cooker Italian Beef Hoagies

Chicago-Style Italian Beef Hoagies

Veggie Italian Hoagies

Italian Sausage Hoagies

The Best Philly Style Italian Hoagi...

Chicken Cacciatore Hoagies

Italian Beef

Italian Beef

Grilled Eggplant Parm Hoagies

Chicken and Sausage Hoagies

Italian Beef Stew

Italian Beef Ragu

Italian Beef Sandwiches

Italian Beef Meatballs

Italian Beef Rollups

Chicago Italian Beef

Italian Beef Recipe