hoosier cream pie

Grandma’s old-fashioned sugar cream custard pie topped with a buttery &amp; crispy sugar cinnamon brûlée coating

Vanilla Sugar Cream Pie

/ 529.1 g heavy cream

/ 150.6 g granulated sugar

/ 1.5 g kosher salt

cornstarch

Tablespoons / 56.7 g butter, softened and unsalted

Tablespoon / 13 g Rodelle Fair Trade Vanilla Extract

Tablespoons / 56.7 g butter, melted and unsalted

sugar

cinnamon

/ 1.2 g nutmeg

Preheat the oven to 350 F. To a heavy bottom pot over medium heat, add the heavy cream, sugar, salt, cornstarch, and butter. Whisk to combine and then continue to whisk until the mixture comes together and forms a thick pudding-like consistency. This will take ~15-20 minutes. Do not let it boil as you risk breaking the mixture (it could curdle).

Once the mixture is very thick, turn the heat off and add in the vanilla and mix to combine.

Pour the mixture into the prepared pie shell and pop it in the oven to set the custard for 10 minutes. Remove the pie from the oven and set the oven to broil with a rack 6-8” from the broiler.

Make the Pie

In a small bowl whisk together the sugar, cinnamon, and nutmeg. To the hot pie, pour the melted butter over top of the custard. Next, sprinkle on all of the cinnamon mixture.

Take a few strips of aluminum foil (or pie crust guards) and cover the crust of the pie. You’re doing this so you won’t burn the crust in the next step.

Pop the pie back into the oven under the broiler for 30-60 seconds. You just want to caramelize the sugars and brûlée the top.

Make the Topping &amp; Finish The Pie

Pull the pie from the oven, remove the foil and allow to cool completely at room temperature. Once cooled, wrap the pie in plastic wrap and place in the fridge for a minimum of 4 hours or overnight.

To serve slice and serve as-is or with some cinnamon nutmeg whipped cream.

Chill Out Then Serve

Wow, I had never had a vanilla sugar pie and this was sooooo delicious!  My family went back for seconds and want to know when I will be making it again!

Top 1 hoosier cream pie recipes from across the web

The most viewed hoosier cream pie recipes by Recipe Cart users, saved from over 6,000 sites. Or, go to our Recipe Search Engine

Top Tags

Vanilla Sugar Cream Pie

Top 1 hoosier cream pie recipes from across the web

The most viewed hoosier cream pie recipes by Recipe Cart users, saved from over 6,000 sites. Or, go to our Recipe Search Engineic_arrow_forward_48px

Top Tags

Vanilla Sugar Cream Pie

The most viewed hoosier cream pie recipes by Recipe Cart users, saved from over 6,000 sites. Or, go to our Recipe Search Engine