Step 1

Remove the side muscle from scallops: Pinch the small, tough flap on the side of the scallop and gently pull it away—it should peel off easily. Not all scallops will have them. (See photos in the post.)

Step 2

Prep Scallops: Pat the scallops very, very dry on both sides with paper towels. Season the top sides with half of the salt and pepper and sprinkle with paprika, if using.

Step 3

Heat the Pan: Heat a large, heavy-bottom skillet (stainless or cast-iron) over high heat. Once hot, add the oil and swirl to coat the pan. Heat until it is rippling and just about smoking.

Step 4

Sear and Season: Add half of the scallops, seasoned side DOWN spaced so they aren’t touching. Sear until golden brown on the bottom, about 3 minutes. While they are searing, season the tops with HALF of the remaining salt and pepper and sprinkle with optional paprika.

Step 5

Sear the Other Side: Gently turn each scallop using tongs and add 1/2 tablespoon butter (2 pieces). If the scallops don’t easily release from the pan, continue to cook until they do. Cook for another 1-2 minutes just until done. Scallops are done: when they have a golden-brown crust on the outside and are barely opaque on the sides. They should be slightly firm but springy in the center, not mushy or tough. Always err on undercooking them because you can add them back to the pan to cook longer. You don’t want tough scallops! Once removed from the pan, they will cook a little from residual heat.

Step 6

Repeat: Transfer the scallops to a shallow dish or rimmed plate along with any accumulated butter or juices. Clean out the pan, then repeat with the second batch of scallops.

Step 7

Sauté: Heat the pan over medium-low heat and add the butter to melt. Add the garlic, red pepper flakes, salt, and pepper. Sauté for about 30 seconds, just until fragrant, scraping up brown bits on the bottom of the pan.

Step 8

Finish Sauce: Add the lemon juice and parsley and stir to combine. Season to taste with additional lemon, salt, and/or pepper.

Step 9

Serve: Drizzle the sauce over the seared scallops and serve immediately.